Facing a Revocation of Supervision Hearing in Wisconsin
Recently, I visited a client in jail who was considering waiving his revocation hearing. He was on extended supervision after serving time in prison and worried that an Administrative Law Judge might order him to return to prison for longer than his supervision agent recommended.
That concern is understandable. However, giving up a revocation hearing can mean losing an important opportunity to challenge allegations, present evidence, and argue against additional confinement.
If you are facing revocation of probation or extended supervision in Racine, Kenosha, or elsewhere in Wisconsin, understanding your options before waiving a hearing is important. Learn more about our Probation Violation and Revocation Attorney services.
Why Revocation Hearings Matter
A revocation hearing gives us an opportunity to examine the allegations against our client. Much like a trial, witnesses may testify, evidence may be presented, and attorneys can question the people involved.
These hearings can help us identify weaknesses in the allegations, challenge witness credibility, and learn more about the investigation.
These hearings become especially important when the alleged supervision violation also involves new criminal charges. Information obtained during the hearing may help us better understand the evidence and prepare a defense.
Does a Probation Violation Automatically Mean Revocation?
A violation does not automatically mean someone must return to prison or lose their supervision.
Wisconsin's revocation process considers whether revocation is necessary to protect the public, address treatment needs, or hold someone accountable for their conduct. Depending on the circumstances, alternatives to revocation may be appropriate.
I recently represented a client who faced six allegations at a revocation hearing. We successfully demonstrated that five of those allegations were unfounded.
The Administrative Law Judge found that the remaining allegation, driving without a valid license, had occurred.
However, the judge also considered the time my client had already spent in jail awaiting the hearing. The judge determined that this time had provided sufficient accountability, that additional confinement was unnecessary to control his behavior, and that confinement would not help him obtain a driver's license.
As a result, my client avoided additional confinement.
That outcome illustrates why challenging the allegations and presenting the full circumstances at a hearing can make a difference.
Can an Attorney Challenge the Recommended Revocation Time?
Yes. Even when some allegations are supported, an attorney can challenge the amount of confinement recommended by a supervision agent.
If we successfully dispute several allegations, we can question whether the agent's original recommendation remains appropriate.
We can also examine the policies and guidelines behind that recommendation and present mitigating circumstances that deserve consideration.
For example, a person's positive adjustment while on supervision, efforts toward rehabilitation, and overall conduct may provide important context when determining whether additional confinement is necessary.
Should You Waive Your Revocation Hearing?
Before signing a waiver, speak with an attorney who understands Wisconsin's probation and extended supervision revocation process.
A hearing provides an opportunity to challenge allegations, question witnesses, present mitigating evidence, and argue for alternatives to revocation or less confinement.
Waiving that hearing means giving up those opportunities. The right decision depends on the circumstances of your case, but it deserves careful consideration.
Speak With a Racine Probation Revocation Attorney
If you or someone you know faces probation or extended supervision revocation in Racine, Kenosha, or anywhere in Wisconsin, contact Racine Defense. Attorney Brian P. Dimmer can review the allegations, explain your options, and prepare a defense for your hearing.
Learn more about our Probation Violation and Revocation Attorney services or call today to schedule your free consultation.
February 14, 2020